
MOSCOW TO PLAY HOST TO IMPORTANT GUESTS FROM ISRAEL AND IRAN
By Safa Haeri
MOSCOW-TEHRAN-JERUSALEM 3 Sept. (IPS) Moscow displayed red carpet for high ranking guests from two bitter enemies, Iran and Israel, raising questions and controversies, forcing the Islamic Republic to delay the visit here of Defence Minister Admiral Ali Shamkhani, due also to land here the same time as Israel’s hard line Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.
"It is highly unusual that the trip (of Israeli Premier Ariel Sharon) is coinciding with Iranian Defence Minister Ali Shamkhani's visit to Moscow, during which he is scheduled to discuss military and technical cooperation between Tehran and Moscow", wrote the conservatives-controlled, English-language daily "Tehran Times".
"Either this coincidence is a blunder on the part of the Russian officials, or Moscow, fully aware of the Iranian opposition to the Zionist (Israeli) regime, is doing this intentionally, which would indicate a double-standard policy adopted by the Kremlin officials", the paper said.
"Whatever the case may be, Russia is granting the Zionists (Israelis) a very good opportunity to break out of the diplomatic isolation, which they have experienced since the beginning of the Intifada", the paper pointed out, adding that the move could "also damage the cordial and friendly relations that have existed between Iran and Russia for the past decade", "Tehran Times" warned.
"I don't think that it was planned in advance, but it does emphasize the inconsistency of Russian foreign policy", Andrei Piontkovsky, the director of Moscow's Center of Strategic Research, said of the simultaneous visits.
Nevertheless, there are widespread rumours both in Tehran and in some Arab capitals, still on the impression that non-Arab Iran and Israel keep secret contacts, that Mr. Putin, a former KGB agent, has managed of having both the Israeli Prime Minister and the Iranian Defence Minister in Moscow at the same time in order to accomplish an otherwise impossible mission of reconciling Tehran and Tel-Aviv.
"President Vladimir Putin is desperately trying to maintain Russia's profile as a great power, so it's very important for him that the Russian flag is present in many conflict zones, even when Russia has nothing to contribute and nothing to gain, like in the Middle East," Piontkovsky said.
Independent defence analyst Pavel Felgenhauer said Iran and Israel each had reasons to befriend Russia, a turn-round from the Cold War era when the former Soviet Union armed Israel's Arab foes and the Shah of Iran was a close U.S. ally.
"For obvious reasons, Israel feels itself increasingly isolated and believes that Russia will be sympathetic. And Israel needs all the sympathy it can get right now" he added.
"Russia is still a superpower and can exert a great deal of influence in the region," Sharon spokesman Ra'anan Gissin said. "We would like to coordinate our efforts to face common challenges and threats."
Sharon told Russian journalists in Jerusalem on Thursday that his government was nervous about the spread of weapons of mass destruction to states like Iran and its neighbour Iraq.
"During his talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin, Sharon is also going to discuss the threat caused to Israel by Russia's technological assistance to Iran in developing non-conventional weapons", former Israeli ambassador to Paris Avi Pazner told the French news agency AFP.
The Jewish state accuses Iran, perceived as its most dangerous foe, of attempting to develop a military nuclear programme as well as ballistic missiles capable of reaching Israeli territory.
"During his visit, Shamkhani will discuss with Russian officials forging of a defence, military and technical co-operation based on each country's national laws as well as (pertinent) international conventions", the official Iranian news agency IRNA quoted Mr. Keyvan Khosravi, an Iranian analyst of Iran and former Soviet Union Republics, including Moscow.
The Islamic Republic not only rejects the almost defunct Middle East Peace Process and publicly vows its determination to "wipe out the Jewish State from the region’s map", but is also a firm supporter of Palestinian extremist organisations like the HAMAS and the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, considered by Israel as the groups behind most of the deadliest terrorist bombing and explosions inside Israel.
Sharon is scheduled to meet President Putin on Tuesday, the Kremlin announced, adding the talks will focus on bilateral relations and the situation in the Middle East, avoiding however the Iranian dimension of the talks.
Israel’s Channel 1 TV reported Monday that Israel will propose join aerospace and satellite projects to compensate for the diminished revenue from selling military technology to Iran, in case Russia accepts to limit its arms sales to Iran.
But Itar-Tass news agency said Iran could spend $7 billion-$10b revamping its aging military hardware and that Shamkhani is most interested in planes, attack helicopters, anti-aircraft missile systems, and high-tech rocket systems.
Both Washington and Tel-Aviv accuses Moscow of transferring missile technologies to Iran and expresses concern over Russia’s involvement in the construction of a 1000 Megawatts nuclear powered electricity plant in Bushehr, on the Persian Gulf.
For their part, Iran and Russia rejects the claim, pointing out that the
plant is of civilian nature and that experts from the Vienna-based International
Atomic Energy Agency regularly supervise the works.
Moscow told the United States last year it did not consider itself bound any
longer by the secret 1995 deal which forbid it from selling arms to Iran.
The deal, agreed to by then U.S. Vice-President Al Gore and then Russian Prime Minister Viktor Chernomyrdin, barred Russia from signing new contracts for Iranian purchases of conventional weapons. Existing contracts were to be completed by 1999.
"In any case, our discussions (with Iran) will concern only defensive weapons such as ground-to-air defence systems and conventional weapons", Vice Premier Ilia Klebanov was quoted by Interfax news agency as saying.
"The Prime Minister can count on Russian officials to listen with an understanding ear to his concerns on the issue of terrorism, since it also affects Russia. He also wants to strengthen the existing understanding between Israel and Russia, whose importance he has always recognised and which he has visited several times before becoming prime minister", Pazner added.
"The Defence minister is to hold talks with Russian officials on ways of expanding ties within the framework delineated by the presidents of the two countries (in March)" Iranian analysts said.
"Consultations, exchange of views as well as paving the way to resolving security problems affecting the region and removing deterrents to the establishment of lasting peace and stability in the region are among the main goals behind the visit", Mr. Khosravi added.
The trip is part of an ongoing rapprochement between the two states. Russian Defence Minister Igor Sergeyev paid a visit to Tehran in December last year which was followed by a visit to Moscow by Iranian President Mohammad Khatami in March this year.
Iran sees the warming of ties with Russia as a means of undermining the grip of unilateral U.S. sanctions on its economy.
The United States, which has renewed its sanctions on Iran for another five years, has been criticized for the move by Russia.
Putin said in March that Russia would resume the sale of "defensive" weapons to Iran, despite U.S. criticism.
"The Iranians, like the Chinese, are mostly looking for licensed production, not for off-the-shelf weapons," said Felgenhauer. Iran's shopping list includes battle tanks, MiG-29 fighter jets, long-range torpedoes, so-called smart mines and the long-distance S-200 anti-aircraft missile.
"They want to have a potential to counter, if need be, Western-armed Arab navies, or Western navies, in the Persian Gulf and the Straits of Hormuz," said Felgenhauer. That required sophisticated mines, high-speed torpedoes and air defences. IRAN RUSSIA ISRAEL 3901