
ABOLISHMENT OF STONING IN IRAN SEEN AS NEW VICTORY FOR THE EU
By Safa Haeri, IPS Editor
PARIS 27 Dec. (IPS) The European Union scored another major victory when official religious authorities in the Islamic Republic of Iran were quoted to have decided to abolished stoning, a punishment reserved in the Islamic laws mostly for adulterous women.
The daily newspaper "Bahar" (Spring) quoted Hojjatoleslam Qorbanali Dorri Najafabadi, the Head of the Supreme Court of Administrative Justice as having announced that the practice had been stopped "for a while".
According to Mrs. Jamileh Kadivar, a reformist Member of the Majles from
Tehran, Ayatollah Mahmood Hashemi-Shahroodi, who is the Head of the Iranian
Judiciary, has ordered that execution by stoning should be stopped.
Quoting a "well-informed source", the internet website "Iranian Women" said Friday that in their latest round of talks with Iranian officials, the European Union’s human rights delegations had made the abolition of the degrading punishment one of the conditions necessary for the conclusion of a Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA) with the Islamic Republic.
"The Europeans, during the behind closed-doors discussions, has put stiff conditions, one of them being the abolition of stoning women. Another condition was Iran’s unconditional endorsing of international conventions regarding scraping all discriminations against women. And contrary to Iranian authorities statements that they would not accept any preconditions from the EU, they had in fact accepted all the European’s demands", the "womeniniran.com" website added.
According to both Iranian and EU sources and diplomats, other conditions the European delegation had presented to the Iranian side also included freeing political prisoners, abolishing torture and inhuman treatment of prisoners, ending the ban imposed on more than eighty Iranian independent and reform-seeking publications, responding positively to the Iranian people’s aspirations fro democratic principles, disengaging from support provided to hard line Arab and Palestinian groups opposed to peace with Israel and renouncing to built a nuclear arsenal.
But Mrs. Shirin Ebadi, a prominent Iranian lawyer and human rights activist said it was not fair to credit the European Union or international human rights organisations for the scraping of stoning law and not pay tribute to the uphill struggle the Iranian women and rights groups had engaged for securing equal rights for Iranian women.
A statement by Hojjatoleslam Assadollah Mobasheri, Head of the Islamic Revolution Tribunal (IRT) of Tehran, announcing after the Iran-EU meeting that the Nationalist-religious and the Iran Freedom Movement (IFM) were not considered as groups "plotting to overthrow the Islamic Republic" was seen as a "great achievement" by the European Union’s policy of "positive engagement" with the regime of the ruling Iranian ayatollahs.
Under Iran's strict Islamic law, in place since the Islamic revolution of 1979, men and women convicted of adultery are usually sentenced to death by stoning, with condemned buried in a pit - men up to their waists, women their armpits - and pelted with stones, not too big to kill the victim with the first throws. If the victims manage to dig themselves out, they are acquitted.
Though officials do not always announce capital punishments by stoning, but at least two cases of women being stoned to death last year have been recorded.
But differing interpretations of the Shari’a law have made the issue so sensitive that the government, fearing a backlash by hard line judges, appears unwilling to make the directive public.
According to Mrs. Ebadi, because stoning is not clearly mentioned in the Qor’an, the Muslim’s holly book, high-ranking religious authorities for Shi’a Muslims have different interpretation of the stoning law.
Ayatollah Moosavi-Tabrizi, a member of the Assembly of Experts has told the independent Iranian Students News Agency ISNA that whenever the interests of the State are at stake, or under certain conditions, the stoning prescription could be disregarded, even if it had been clearly instructed by Qor’an.
But other mojtahed, or sources of imitation do not agree with this view, arguing that it is to the Muslim’s societies to adapt themselves with Islamic laws and not otherwise.
The European Union’s "positive engagement" with Iran was seen by many observers as opposed to the Bush Administration’s "iron fist", placing the Islamic Republic among the "evil states", which also includes Communist North Korea and Fascist Iraq.
But better informed Iranian analysts said both the European and American approaches to Tehran are the two sides of the same coin, aimed at "taming" the ruling Iranian ayatollahs in the one hand and opening the Iranian political scene to new alternative.
They also say that the conservative’s unprecedented bowing to the European demands is part of their political plans to put the last nails to the coffins of both President Mohammad Khatami and the "official reformers". ENDS STONING ABOLISHED 271202