Latest ArticlesArchivesForumsRSS FeedGuestbookContact UsSearch

Iran Press Service (logo)

As of January 2009, this site is definitely closed, but you can follow Safa Haeri on his new blog: DAMAVAND at

In Iran, All Roads To Democracy Are Closed

Published Monday, June 19, 2006

By Ebrahim Nabavi (With Safa Haeri)

Rome, 19 June (Rooz Online) Akbar Ganji, the imprisoned Iranian journalist who was released last month and who is currently on a European trip told an audience in Italy that under the current political structure in Iran it was not possible to implement any reforms.

“Iranian officials argue that Iran has an external enemy which plans to attack the country and this enemy is the press and journalists.

“During Hitler’s fascism the Gestapo was created to control and spy on the opposition, Stalin created the KGB for this purpose and Italy a special organization too was formed. But controlling people through the police is the worst way. A simpler way is to give freedom to people. I mean freedom as a process to gain information”, he said.

Mr. Ganji, condemned to ten years imprisonment, spent six years behind bars on fabricated charges of “propaganda against the regime” and “offending the leader” etc. However, he was allowed by the Iranian authorities to travel abroad to receive the Golden Pen Award from the Congress of the World’s Journalists Association and afterward came to Italy where he was proclaimed the Honorary Citizen of the city of Florence.

In Rome, he gave a press conference and presided over a ceremony for the launch of the book written by Mr. Ahmad Ra’fat, an Iranian-Italian journalist about the freedom of the press in Iran. The book “Spring of the Press” is centred on the life and struggle of Mr. Gani for freedom and democracy.

According to Mr. Ganji, the Iranian Government has formed centres on the issue of an imaginary “enemy”. “Iranian officials argue that Iran has an external enemy which plans to attack the country. The way this enemy wishes to accomplish its goal is through cultural invasion for which it needs a domestic base. The Iranian press is that domestic base. Therefore, officials argue, journalists are agents for the enemy, and suppressing them is a national measure”.

Explaining the strange structure of the Iranian theocratic system, Mr. Ganji said that in analysing the situation in Iran one needed to pay attention to two things: “The legal structure and the real structure of the regime. In the legal structure, which is based on the Constitution, almost all the power rests with the leader and the institutions under his control. Even though separation of powers is provided for in the Constitution, this is not the actual arrangement.

You may think of a referendum about the regime, as this is provided for in the Constitution too, but in reality a referendum must be approved by the Guardians Council which is controlled by the leader and we know that it will be vetoed”, he noted.

In Iran, All Roads To Democracy Are Closed-Body

“Another way is to amend the Constitution, which is also provided for in the Constitution. But this very document also says that any change of the constitution must be carried out through the supervision of the leader. Furthermore, members of the Constitution Amendment Council too are appointed by the leader”, he pointed out, adding:

“Currently, the general plans of the regime in all fields are determined by the State Expediency Council, whose members are all appointed by the leader as well. As you see, there is absolutely no possibility to reform the system under its legal structure. So if we returned to the events of 8 years ago, the same results would be produced”. [Translators Note: this is a reference to the election of reformist president Mohammad Khatami and the failed attempts to reform the system from within and open it to democratic forces].

“The real structure – as opposed to the legal one – is even worse. The military and security agencies are very strong and they interfere in all facets of life. The power of the leader and institutions associated with him are ten times more powerful than the legal provisions. There is no possibility for any action”, he observed critically.

Continuing with his explanations of the Iranian ruling system, the author of “The Manifesto for Republicanism”, a three parts pamphlet in which Mr. Ganji “teaches” the methods of “pacific resistance by disobedience and no cooperation” said: ”On the other hand, we are faced with meaningless concepts. We have a parliament, but in fact this is not a true parliament. We have a president, but in fact he is only the office manager for the leader. So when we hear the president say something, it is really the leader’s speaking through the president’s voice. All the things that are said about the nuclear issue are the views of the leader which are stated by others”.

“We do not want war, we want peace. But to achieve it we must talk”, Mr. Ganji continued, arguing that “The requirement for world peace is world disarmament. Is Europe ready to defend a general disarmament?”, he asked, before describing the efforts of the Ahmadi Nezhad Government to nuclearise Iran as “unwise”.

I agree with civil disobedience, a method used all over the world but which in Iran bears a very high price.

“From the view of Iranian intellectuals, the position of the Iranian government regarding nuclear energy is not a wise one. They (authorities) argue that because Israel, Russia, China, the US and Pakistan have nuclear weapons it is our right to have them too. But this is pouring fuel on fire and promoting war. Instead, we should spread the word of disarmament”, he said, adding that “Another step for us is to defend direct talks with the US. Iran can protect its interests better if it engages in direct talks”.

“I am against revolution and view myself as a reformist. I agree with civil disobedience. This is a method that is used all over the world. But in Iran civil disobedience bears a very high price. We need the spiritual support of Europe and the world”, he stressed, adding that “Human rights are not an internal issue, but a human issue and the concern of the whole world”.

At the end of his talk, Ganji reiterated that he opposed revolution and criticized Europe for not well treating exiled Iranian journalists.

“These journalists are under pressure and continues to be viewed as foreigner’s spies. Europe must take more steps in the direction of changing this situation. I can raise even more demands but am sure I will receive negative responses. This is why I will stay content with spiritual support”, he concluded his observations, before leaving “The Eternal City” for the “The City of Lights”. ENDS GANJI 19606


Comments on this page are closed.

As of January 2009, this site is definitely closed, but you can follow Safa Haeri on his new blog: DAMAVAND at

In Iran, All Roads To Democracy Are Closed-Main
In Iran, all roads to democracy are closed, but we have to open it through methods like civil disobedience.



Want to express an opinion?
Participate in our user forums.

Impressions from our site?
Share them in our Guest Book.

Got Feedback?
Send a letter to the editor.


Powered by the Big Medium content management system. sitemap xml